Skip to content
SF-2026-000773UnverifiedDeep State & Intel Agencies

b thisone Y, uear PARE=UVery report intdocument is clCIA copy from labeled

A 32-page declassified document from the CIA reading room recording the proceedings of a scientific advisory panel — historically known as the Robertson Panel — convened in mid-January 1953 to evaluate U.S. Air Force unidentified-flying-object reports. The text, marked 'Copied From Illegible Original,' summarizes third through final sessions held on 15–17 January 1953 attended by CIA personnel, Air Force Project BLUE BOOK head Capt. Edward Ruppelt, Dr. J. Allen Hynek, and panel scientists. It describes briefings on Air Force UFO collection and analysis procedures, Project STORK support at Battelle Memorial Institute in Columbus, Project PINKLE/PINKLE instrumentation watch by the Air Force Cambridge Research Center, and Project CROSSED German V-1/V-2 intelligence comparisons. The panel reviewed roughly two dozen case histories — including Bellefontaine Ohio, Tremonton Utah, Great Falls Montana, Yaak Montana, Washington D.C., and others — and studied gun-camera motion-picture film analyzed by the U.S. Navy Photo Interpretation Laboratory. It concluded there was no evidence of a direct threat to national security, no evidence the objects were extraterrestrial or foreign craft, and that the volume of low-grade reports risked clogging intelligence channels. The panel recommended stripping UFOs of their 'special status,' debunking via mass media (including suggestions of Walt Disney cartoons and figures like Arthur Godfrey), and broad public education, while cautioning about associated dangers such as misidentification of real enemy craft and psychological vulnerability to hysteria.

cia.govIncident Jan 1953Discovered Jul 4, 20261.4 MBdocument
sha256:b1b8c38a5359b84a5376

Description

Declassified CIA-held report of the scientific advisory panel convened in January 1953 to review U.S. Air Force UFO (unidentified flying object / 'flying saucer') data. The badly degraded photostat records four days of meetings with CIA personnel, Air Force representatives (Ruppelt), Dr. J. Allen Hynek, and panel scientists chaired by Dr. H.P. Robertson, examining case histories, gun-camera film (Tremonton, Great Falls), radar interference, and recommending a public debunking/education program. Widely known as the Robertson Panel report.

Claims

  • The panel concluded unanimously there was no evidence of a direct threat to national security in the objects sighted.

    85%
  • The panel found no evidence that the sighted objects were extraterrestrial craft or foreign (Soviet) hardware.

    80%
  • The panel recommended a public education/'debunking' program to strip UFOs of their special status and reduce report volume.

    85%
  • The Tremonton and Great Falls film objects were assessed by the Navy Photo Interpretation Laboratory and panel as likely birds, balloons, aircraft or reflections.

    70%
  • Reported correlation of radioactivity with unidentified light objects at two Los Alamos-area cases was judged inconclusive.

    60%
  • Mass media including Walt Disney cartoons and personalities such as Arthur Godfrey were suggested as vehicles for the education program.

    70%

Events

  1. Jan 14, 1953

    Third and fourth panel sessions

    Thursday sessions with CIA personnel, Ruppelt and Hynek; briefings on collection/analysis, Project STORK, Project PINKLE.

  2. Jan 15, 1953

    Fifth panel session

    Discussion and study of documentary material; Hynek presented a paper; individual case histories examined.

  3. Jan 16, 1953

    Final panel session

    Panel reviewed proceedings, drafted conclusions and recommendations including debunking/education program.

  4. Jul 1, 1952

    Tremonton, Utah sighting

    Gun-camera film case analyzed by Navy Photo Interpretation Laboratory.

  5. Aug 24, 1952

    Great Falls, Montana sighting

    Motion-picture case reviewed; objects suspected to be aircraft reflections.

  6. Jul 28, 1952

    Washington D.C. sightings

    Case history among those discussed in detail.

Dates mentioned

1953-01-151953-01-161953-01-171952-07-291952-08-011952-07-021952-08-251952-09-021952-08-05

Keywords

Entities

Extracted text (OCR)
Ys
-
AYP oat
date gem wi hee ee an

¢


ings

Lae
are rs

story oF 2}

Fort Ti

+ meee eft Pane
A 3605 CLAM Ob Fotics

e..
wiay

moeuti

Lx

i

us

ete

te.

~~
ta

~~

ol

ts


news

peewee ke

eee oe

ae

ISESRANDUN POR: Ancictan’ Dirscter fee Setcarifio Intelligenco

«3 of tho Citic

-y fe Bern a od aie
Tn ollg wee 37} USAC tae aG Sach

Ysidoreisiel Vigirg Cajcetc, vary

fe faa - D hs Bam vot le . - - . L
pe, A bode? nictexs 2G Of the OST svi sor7 Pozo. :

Do An uroryY

oa tet
Anse OL Sour gg Mere

n,n se wae ame

Meta wet tee weep’ re an

sor congidsres.er

ebjcetat st to 4 Desi Eos ears

w aay ° ey,
et Gan Nhe aS 4 | LD Un
Nee cps fe Vows tee fsorn: a -
Merete Dav Losmeas Snrey Ebvo ge Sst
. ¥ a yy
€ 1 .
wval 3
etal

«
z
1
?
i
i
‘

emwineit ame SNE ME sat Aan ee” aterm 4

gore tet pees

see ©

1 enema

we igs nee a

eet etd igs, UL ade wm de

SLC LS Pre ea Beadle os e's

vara Ginter, oe

Boe. oth dehy my

en en ae Sed

mynd gar <a cee oe
. 26 OE Soo

Co

ee es ey RR, ; ; no i 3 : :
wee we Fob ewes . = i . 4 : TPs . evs. - 2

ss of tha wosting2. | i
A TiS cv Catocen th Cah 4. . :
Gud Ayo .
Wy NLR eal nie She! .
a. ae «base eal eas we
Pie MYST uoned tho nestics, Ke fotha ;
neta t amte A. rete £ J
E2572 fils wrod. 3
r fa: % Tea oy” Losaset :
t - 0. w Ae Sa. ef. ANGUS , outs ered Eis $s). :
« . - . ony “ a] 4s . : . *

qv, oa Se

—

ete qe
ciel =

2, uy
ar Seesepee woonas ewe}
: :

ee Ci haria an . val . . ” : j

>}


. . id . a
. .
a-
Es. Peievtisa : i
aX» plcias oem 7
ead OVALS ON.
,
z
i
. ae,
wah wee ele
oe sos a oo -¢ bes a c
. - ‘ - 8 os 1 5 mre nd eens © Pe
‘ ae . . . ve. ase age ae “A a?
7 - eilidatt lle righ. pith ore 2 Sa? Suk nL tO 4
. :
. RLS kL SL tine On Lt, rs ee cc
: Se ws - ee re , wey are)
5
z Meas 5 reelde. 6 eS ne ee . soe
: i
- oe set "ea . . - . te Le - oe aes
A . .
: » ee ee
5 . Beery Fe wee
:
2 ‘ : “w an an “oa. wu Sakae O wo aor
; oan - + . we, | tee ryt sas Moet .
Ly é. rs w. . e .
74 . ne me : _4 . . en: . nr Sah . . : re “8
. . . ve ones ae oF
.
¢ .
j
;
i
}
q ne
: s
Loe
_
gen rere MES
. Ne aly
“Copied From \
ra
e rt
iegible Orighe ae
eee ene ee


rend sg ok enrol et sean teers

das Ape ener me mt

rey

ea eS

er

TegengDe.
The third and fourth meotings of the Penol were hold Tnuseday;
15 Jamary, eexmencing ab 6700 vith a tuesnour becak for lunchoone
Besides Panol nucbera art CIA pereonnel, Mr. Ruppolt end Dr. Hynsk
veto prescat for both sospions. Inthe wornerg, lie, Ruppelt ton
Rinved his briefing on - HSI _colisction amd cnrlsess Progouurede

The Projost STORK suppart at Rattolle Mqwrisl Institute, Colmhus,

»

was doseritel by Dre Uyock, A raczoc? ef cane histeries weirs aise
cussed in dol amie motion pletuto fila of cease was Ghose

A twa hour teak fof -lusth vas: taker at-PW.

earns eaneore At
TIVASMS Aes TOO -
es ee ee A ae ty rae ©

At U,00 Weucs LE: Col. Ores gave 9 MGersimsts beleriag of

Froject PINKLE, | tho | anyosts is MOET’ Frejust contre 3 ep The AT

Forze Natesrelezical Re tareh Cextes ee Cetiei€sa, Hate ty tala

briefing te pointed out the pany ee olen? ‘of auocie? Wo cid mys

eL-now snstrontation wotehes er pour ot oe ong searGuing for

bigatirges of U, ¥,0,°a.

“At1615 Peig. Gon, WID4 | Go iad fods sd the molest 3 WATS

*. . br

AD/St. Gonara LGarlerd capsessed hia -mapre.7t G2 (aa Taarlte
girorts end rite threw parser L opiuiesdt

a, That geeatur vrs of “Mn Sagas dbs ey..t 2 62438508 za

x fo ate, Bee er Re a eee eee DA ved ?
ese Paola (Pos a oaee w Uno 4 5; sine) eu ° mA ULI.
“, Wa . Ser
kus a Wreee? th / requis el iY bi sree) hia wee GS
.


ee be dln Me ere ta te

tem

ot tig AB HOS oe

NW

ba

Oo

That vigcrous ofvort should bo mio to dwlasoify os many
of ths roporta as povoiblo.
That cong Increase in the ATO eaction acvoted to U.F.O.

araiysio was indleated. ~~~...

This werting wes edjouened et 172000 _

Tis L1Pth ueroten ef tho Penal convened at OXO vith the 3

aw.

pesvenngl procs:

Wicfitg on his f4itec wontho eqporicnta th Wasnizgien Ge +

to witeh be resorred, Following Ms, Fouwwac$'s precemation, &

i!
co
ta
[hot
ray
4
fy
i

¢
ba
Pal
ee
is
wy
$
ms

—Siseday (with tho amopts.on-

of Brig. G73, Garlari)e
Fron (300 = 100 thave was geezer} dissuseien ana etudy cv
yorerenzte micriel, Also, bre nynck reas & FTopares Peper maidng

cortein ebsutvations ard conslucionso™ At ACO Meg Fournst gave a

Offteo for UL.F30.?8 ani he5 possonal comaliciers, Tame Vas

conticsrable dinsucsioa of. tydivieunl o253 histerics ef olg entivga

motor of additional case hict apices Ware exandncd end diemzscs

- with Mosevas Feurnst, Ryppolt, tal Ryrcks Tho nscting edjormes

teaotnans ©
i

Marner,

cement eet ene a mis I omer ate +

at 1200 for Jusithetn.

: — FRITATAPEERIONS

oes Thia oacoioa ops et UO. ‘Besidos Farol moubasto and GTA
cossonnal, Dr. Ryavk was presen Te Ted Ve simu, o3 Penol

was weosent-at~ -Ahia nesting foes the finch tims. Prossces

of tho moctinis vea reviewed ty tha Pusol Chiurrza end tentativs


Sores let Ley | 4) Gineucaien Tollucd. i Gd tentative

sg test the Cheirvea enc td

“topo ecnaider-d,

Craft o repost

out

ad

he LUC) ths AnvSkej

A diacuacen a cc

fl
re
*,
bd
«
eas
a
Sad
oO
Go
&
pet
£
Nw

rousn ores& tO.

cet _¢
> fisny hooey

te
2
Cy
wa
3
aa

er

ps
©
a
1%,

9 opiehon3 out

fe, Le 2 wad Pooeok

tea ep peee sa ns
atime

oi ase

othe

ST en ae ea eae

ee a ee

. a ie =.

Ub, TSS eee fs rorerey i
Pr A ee

Bor mn clase

cen”
a atl
ae a youl

opie? * pyigin®
nee one

ae

Sem

i cine rae

get Oe

a mae:

apa dena omit: mE Foe

ott st 1g I

wmpee

Meet EY ESAS SRIOUS CS PANES
. ro

mS ee ae ter, oe ee

The Panel Meubera wero frrsezsed (a0 bavo bear cthore, imeivd~

ing O/SI e-roonncl) fn the lock of cud data in tho great rajersiy
of cace bistesicss alse, tn the Isck of uposuy followup cus Erisisdt 7
to the modest alse end lisited fact itics ef tha ATID ceotion cons itacd.

fpong ths caso hictirfes ef ofccisteant. clemvince ¢ Gicovised in Cetrii

were the felieings

Bolicfor, ntains,- Oni (1 fagucs -1952) p-Tresonteay Utah (2 duly 25£2)3_

Great Polls, Megtara (25 fuguct 1059); Toak, Moscara {2 Scpleree

2952); vachtestos D, C, oven (29 faly 1992): end Eoreca ALP 3.,

CP

xO

(5 2esust 3952), Pert iven, Michigan (29 duly £052): ara

Proiyud Tota, Fe2nd (10 Ct toe 9583),

Adter rovios ond Cleovestoacl these eccra (rad nboot 23 othcre, -

in ers dotati), tho Fancl comubntid thes peccopsolle expianatiers

could $2 cezgestid Lor rast efchtio z.

—
$40

Bond Puy doduetton ard esientis

Eethed 46 could by indatsd (fiven addbvions]l cata): theat- ether eocos.

weeks

nisht be cciainel faa cietics consent. Phe Ponal polmci cut tek

daatility o? tho vitucases te 2

that conslusivs copier ieas ecu etted fer cvcry eons

reperted, Purthesroro, Ta ved ececldsread thw, nore. Aly: £6 vowi2

be oa grost waste of offers to Uy to Soleo rash ef Une CAGES

UALCES Cusn eoulea vouda bovis a tessuteg wt educcsioral progtoc

woweel

(sco toles), Ghoarritis “8 of Cleghoo Pers wocu wefeves ved toa ekso

eps

‘Siveo olespis (eezantéics)

wae mr mrt abe

cet: om 0 i aa aban de Atm Harn Ae

that "otrange things im tho oxy* had boon reserdcd for huvireds of
yoaros It appesred chicos that there us3 no aingls explasaticn
fer a rajority of tho things seun, The prescaco of raucr ami aptro= |

nomi¢al urccialiste on the Penol proved of voluo at orce in their

- ponfident recomition of phoemccat rolated to their Ticlde. It wo

epparcnt that oposialiccs io exch cddivicnal folds Pa piyeholesy,
metcorology, aeridysunito, orn BAcnolosy ona rilitary air oparaticrs
youd oxtend tho abiltiy ef tho Fracl to resegnica many rare cates
gorios of Mttle-tanm phonoscnte —--——-

OU FAoK% Ch DASE

Tay Panel consludci wamewsly that hero wan no ovidente of

a dircet-threst to rational senmity in tho objests sightod. -—-.-

Rhea were wnsnpiaines

Instancoy of ®Foo Fignvers® wore cited

qaonenena eighted by-acrersft pilots during orld Nox If in both

European oxy] Far Esst theaters of opcratioa cnomein Bboile of licst®

would (iy neat or wali tha efreramt and rancvct sspidly, Th:

bolicved to te olonizesiotic (ciutian to St. Elro'n five) er alertrce

we aw

arnotde phorcnera ¢» psooibly Light seficctiens fron ice erysteds

4n tho abs, wwe their cruact caus ot miyure yan aover dotinedts Pet)

Pobsrtesu shi Alsarca oud bona coma.’ kn tho isresuigee son of -

these phunczesa, ba David Te Gejeng (Peofciier of Gevohysics at _
tha Univcrelty.of Cali voraia at: Jos-drsele:) fe Loltarod to hove
boca tho nest knoviccigeable parson 6n this subjent. Ff tho tora

Uijeing cancexvs" hed tecn porvler in 1943 «= 145s 4 1.539 objesws uous


hme eee

ee ;
SEE

have boon co Taboicd. It vas intcrosting thst in at least two

eaces revicttod thet tha objest eishtcd was categorized by Robert con :
2 Alvarez eo pootably "Foo Pightcra’, to dato unuzpleined bit nvet

darzeroua; + tary verte not hapez thas.to diczwiss the sightinge by

eciliscs thea vwirau, Tt vas theirs feoliny thet theza phonmisn’ oro

not toyons. ths cezain of present knovladze of physical colenss, beyois.,  _-

230 POSS Pere er soya eat Fa
[aon ed CBS EEPOE BS $ret wtb nnn eee

Hyves the Pansies orfaton that eeso of the Aix Poreg consisn WS

ver ULF.O,9s festuithostanding Ais Dofonce Command amdoty over fest —

weeer tresks) vas pootabbhy caused by pablic pecesure. The result

tortsz ig thes the Aue Poree has-inszitvted a fino channel for. i,

ah

“ing perorts 6f quaply onypthing enyend 0733 in vhe ely and

o

Pils to urducstamd, This hes boson portioularly cncourezad in pops oso oo
doy setdeles on vhirendoetaer cabjects, cuch as apace travel cri

poictzo fiction, Tho re ault 48 tho ries resoipt of lovezrade rope

which vera vo cvetload chirnols of cottunteation with matapial quite 50 2
Arsclevest to hoctilo obj-vets thet might sons day _erposr, Thos Faneh = oo

agrecd gentrally that thio miss cy poemquality reports containing

UMivls, ifiung, ecientific data vao cf no valuos . Gite tho opposite,  _ a
4% wac posuibly danzcrouo in having a military corvice foutes public

Consacn in ®nowtermel meandering Uehts™, Tho inplicution boing, |.
girce tha inicsested sacncy wan rilltery, that tloga objscta uote

er nicht ta potentinl direst threats to national vecumity, fArserd=>  -
iusly, the nicd for desmhesisotion macy itself eppurent.: Gusautte

ta G pUcoiLle wiichuiensd promroam cro emmreatat bolew


It wan tho epinion of Ds, Robartson that tho "raucer* problea a
had been fouyi to be diffarcat in rature fra’ tho detection ana _-
inveatication of Gorran Vel ard Ve2 Guided niosiles prior to thot

@. 24.46 MO79

oporational uce in World Yar If, In this 192291944 antoliigonts

operation (CROSSED), there was oxmollent imtelMecnss era by June
1944 there wae ratewdal crisexeos of the aclotents ef "haravaro”

obtains’ fray crested wehiclot in Sxedens Yate evilene cave the ~~

Givestinating text a besie uron vnich to cnecates The atscate of en
Pherdvare? recubties-fromvacspininnl UsP.0.- sightinga lecds 6 at oe Sd

ofsthe wip) nature to the 2200 probles. The seautta ef thoi invesiie —

ration, to date, ttroncle InMiecste that no evictss of hostile cet
a CJ Tote 7¥ : _

sk 77 5 ~~ 2. wane - ow er OS WE 4+ Se =
cr Ganga? otiste, —Purthestoze, the crorcns TOpertint oyu Wear a
_ ¥
Fe pone ce ne ge

fe Beene die ants -
a Gs. passe) BEES - ay. Usin Sh

i

bove Littl valu: in the eis3 ef éeteas:

as a pe TREE = at Wee sgar Tt pheceerne  - ee ee
tlotsl afeerats ot quidea miesi leer Uae Geen ceriiiens Therdcars®

ye ANG 3 TCA PENT AT, TH ys -
ss ne awn aa &: a eet area. Set nwvaane. wade Py

TA wee Sntesastion Lo nota that nos ef tho ments of Cho
Fancl vora leath is secope thes this otech pight- to viaksed ty cevoe 8 oe

torrestrial intcliigany wines Of sone sort, Gens Cayo What _th-t

nos fini ves any cvidacs thet related ths objects eighted te sycus
Qravclera. Ms, Fonet, is hin prosontation, ab. 3 how ho bed elin-
{rated each of tha keemn-and poooale eazsce or virttingn leaving nin
ci x APA hy o at ter Cy Oa ot, me Xs eran aero 0 Fare Taye agen &
Cenve: 2 vhs AGL £8 vca. Cay G89 TS SEL, Jil: tye Moser weld eAUBIV'S

wee Phares an,
ut, rm mip eee

Lay

Yee, ne, - we . ms mnepeyes wee et Kaw stay toon
bostoround ao am econo den’ cogiguwr ard Se chmicsl


officer (Froject Orficar, BUJEECOK for 15 non tho) could not bts
slighted. Rowover, tho Panel could not ‘escort « ary of tho ¢29038 =
sighted by him becauco they ware rav, unovaluated roperte.
Terrestrial oxplon:tiona of the sightings ware suggested in scx
eases and-in othcro tho timo of sighting was co chort aa to causs
suspieion of visual inpressions, It wag noted by Dr. Goudaatt ami
othors that axtraterroutrial crtifects, if thoy Cid exists, aro ko — -
couse for alarny rathor, tiey cro in tho rezin of nvturel poomsnvar Pos
subject to solontifis study, ust as come mya wore at tho tim
of their diccovery 20°25 30 youra 030. Tris was on stiituds ia
vinieh Dy, Robertson did sot const, a3 ho falt thet euch ertiferta
Soe ee

would bo of fmacéinto and crest contern mst only to tho U. 5. tay

to ell countries,  (Fething Mio a comion- tarest to unite propis34)

Dr. Pege noted tint rrecsat astronon gai Muewisdsa os the coke eet
pysten rakes the cxtotenee of dncelligent waing? (cs we Imou tho Pp. nd
torn) cleevhere themor the cosra ectecraly wallisch end tha so se
concentration of their attention by any controllicis means configed 00
to any ono cenfiurnt of the eavth cvite propste: mews
nie cage van soneidercad clanifiocnt bewcus. of tho a.collenS ots
dosvuentary evidw nr an tho Yor ef Redrchtens mothea piotcra fites
(about 2600 feerca)e Tho Peasl studied those flirc, the evco history, ;
VCs Jalerpro lea, ed -reseived a t: tefing bo penresentatives of
tho USN Photo Inteswetetation Leboratervy oa their an ciyeds ov his

a4

film, ‘fhis tea had exotic? (ay MF eves roquest, Gryrestictoly


100) aun-hours of professional and subsprofesaionel tins in tho |

Proparetion of graph plots of LeUvidwnal france of tho fn, shoes
ing apparant ard relativo motion of objects ena weriation in thels
light intensity, It vas the opinion of the P.T.L. representatives

that tha objests pichted vere 29% binds, biltoons ce of4ssram,

wore "not potleations because these was no dll sudaaz wails posait2
throws 63° ¢f aro” art vere, therevore, "aos FS os ti
Dotien ond variation in -lisns Antissdt:
pleyed, Whllo the Pool Merbere wv

enthucicsa, dnfesivey smd axtens ef of

could not eccert tha cesaliciens “reavied. — G25 Of- tha Fiong fxs 08 |.

théia wee ao Lele:

a, Ac EMS OE uvheal odsent Cun Yocdus:

as

OF Cunlich: vitheus*bliakicet thes.
b Although an data vas evallsbls cated 72

polyetlgiia. tehicon in teighs enoli

rntions, 6isc2 end teightsscass_ of tha
censidurod isoncly to tousest bisa, poréiivcecdy occ
tno Fenol wicwed a thest fila shovien hash rotieativar
Gf oorguhls dultetebt can digut.

Go P.I:bs é:. eimies of the objests signoa oo Sete ‘hut,
bluish-wade i in cole. would ba oomestod gu cce.a of

a
iv
Se
—
a
‘oy
‘

O2 Oh rofrethaen vould obs ncg oT iis persicas

ye ee
wee


1 Pm ati ™

i : i
eM A Nm Rr Hh Le sme Mh a Te

Were ore

teagth poe e,

dq.

Os

f.

Ge

he

i.

jo

ee ae

Objects in the Great Falls case woro bolieved to have

protably buen eirerant, and tha bright Mghto ouch reflestions,

Thoro vas no valid reason for thy attcxopt to relatos tho objests

in tho Travonton sighting to those in the Great Falls sight»  ==—=~S
ing. This ray have boon due to micunicrstanding fa their
directive. The objesto in the Groat Falle eifntirz aro

strongly. oucpcoted of being reflostions of aLreratt kasim %0

ave bosn in tho area,

The intensity eherzo in the Trematen Wehts vag t.

fer acsoptance of the P.I.L, hypethests that ths Cpprsu7 --:
motion end chancirg intensity ef_the ligata desie ited axtranaly
high opod 48 BEALL erbitral p.tha.

Apparont lack of cuidansa_of dnvestigniora by thee fastliear -
with U.F.0, reperio ard aeplen-téons.

Aralysle of ligat intcasity of objocte nado fren duplicate

rether than origiv:1 flu, Ths erjginal Mila was pote to

have Graka Ushtor_boekcremd (offooting relusits teéghts233°

ef objezt) end the objects eprcared mash lees brignts

Hathed of otleining data ef Meht intunsity appeared Soult; ;

fo ants hed boon ebiained_co tho. songitavitys of sscochtera

fil» to. ligh 1% Cf various fnvcandtica ueine Pao cer:

‘J

ue

typo at the exsa loas opininzs,


ener

aa

nak ag, AS Maden AO

ratte

pie emilee pee Set hl A wre

whem on se

k, Hand "Sitter" froguension (cctatrable fron carly part of
Tresontea fila) vere not renoved frem tho Note of the
Pginzle pasa plote® at the end of the fin.
Thy Panol bolioved strongly that tho cata avatlebss ca ths
pichting vao ourfieioat for ponitive dccat Af2rsthon 4¢ further data
is obtainyd by photegwarbite prlyetLyless "p Sues tolisesa relezecd

neax the aite under cimilas weathes corliticn, enithin? tiie Slight

2 ~-~ *» ‘, wah mw dey - os
t4 potlestion ehesattoricties with cospstcne © mpl tasie T2262 and -

ea

calsulatiny cppare

treotas Tb wao coutivicd that S22 reo eo? cseh

nothensef-alus in an efusatdenal ¢F

| oad
”

atly lend to creditetie cis

*
os aha ee te. . & an
AREER ehr avidas Cle io Ui wus A rte) au e-

et
i
ra
be
ty,
t4
Pd
|
°
“5
ral
aL
.
&
Lr)
oo
rj
ns
» *
ej
oO
a
rs)
Lan
s *
ia)
o
ct

1952) eoald pst bo juctitied, Teves felt tht these weal orc Lue Pe

eny intvells2 poomaining povgven shea
kev c2 e “Oy Ab Ie ing Sb Ce F

BOT TL ero ty Ooh eee}

Can?


epee

FO el

aa

1 6 arene yah anne aes mh ee ti

:
*
é
¢

eho a at taanegende

Ate a ne maine

ee me AO aa PN RE ge ns

wees

en

“e

nL eee Ted

ERIN RIGAE_ DRS

Tho Panol “cnoare woro Jo eer

elthough ovidenss of any-Aiea2t 4
wholly lacking, rolatsd dargcva might woll eset rosulting Press
a, Mictdentification of cetval canny artitasta ty dsotenca ot

porsons21.

)

be ~Overlending of cessecnty repomtirs channels with Pfalse

inforavtion ("noise to sieral-ratic® enalsap-Racknct) a ~~

Go Sublortivity of publia to ewe hroteria and greater wale

CO PSnAiONe Canty wrpcheleagionl write.

CTA, tho Tarst two of thoze r

a?

viS9 Gevellijenso Cpe

Sogestens ET SA mo bo te
ably yates fh2. AP Gas .Ue fe Se

ee. rd ay eC PPT Da, ee er aot - fn ae gts - _
eeetSitcd fm a renation to thy (Mivie~ eavcer™ ensave, eo UP popotde
oa Pe Spyies . a “

ans ephy dowrcnicd Poperts, 2

tg rcunsd.

derony

ha awmecepliche 4 Wr op ¢2u

Rohe Sats maT wipt d

perae a we Lee Gane? ek:
Fn. - eee en “aN yp? ah "v4 Ne TPs ~ se, a
faa pap peencsrd ty ATES choglet qgctumsrade leanideot er ofsiciety

wn 3 Ans

ayoum: Tone tee tem in ~ otew 1°,

mee. “sc . - fea ge ore ot ae .
pats LAP eshoeed ebissaa an ce stain CwTawiris EST okt GA Lee Alerts

oP hanes Ne

sy, i a ee er ee eT xe ae
Tuy OF CLAMS C8 Vit CliGis Gh als

ord

ae wpe ny wee ot ve

spe ye ge

cr ar)

evarenses ¢P gcuurhc moucure3 sow cuch lecations, On tne other

hen’, Ancva had tesa no sightings in the vicinity of ccusitive

related AD cctablishzznts wile thers vere ereasionajly multiple 2. ._
casos of vaseplainsd aizhtings in nonesivategic crece, Purthermero,  - _.
there eppearce to to no Icgtesl relntionship to porvJation scutcro.

Tno Panel could find yd ressysecplanaticn fe> 4cee clustera,

vax noted, hevaver, that if tocrestvsel artifact were to te cootrwed
>

5

Tuwty ths

a
va
3
‘a
g
iS
g
io!
ic
3
|,
a
cP?
bw J
Q
vb
*j
pid
o
é
tf
“)
f)
i]
il
|
]

4% usuld te

vother then esntral 0.8,

She Fea wags cf the epivica chat tha pocgent ATIC pregran to.

pleco CO iseressive Sy ro cucreo ennerac In the’ naris of veric:

odsport, cowtvol tovo> orerstora vould probably protuce livtlo “alue
uble dria related to UFO, tae Novever, it was recognised that _
euch actica would tend to ellay peblic concern da the cudjest untsi

an educational program_red-tekenieffest. It vas beMevel that pros oa ee

curciort of thira carsras was polly the result of rudlic pressure “ee

in duly 1952, With the poos remits of the yowelong Projects

QWIGKLS pregrom of 22-hour instrumentation Ketch {two farsa of —

film showing nothing cistinzutshsblo), a videcssad Frogvan of thy-

wetcbing weald notte expostad-to ylold mzi dis:ct data of wale, 0 2
Trere was conclaccable discussion of a pocolblo “chy patral® by

aratewr anteoncmcs (Iyaek) endl videsanzls ccaccas (ace). Be, Fego

and Do. Rotiewlaen polnted oud that aturenent a considevabla Iynatica:


: i
fos an ate ty, et te ere NN a8 Malad

1 regen eee

ot wre ot ce

ee ee ee

oe

of tha oky 13 nowve-ard hes been for many yeoresamics curvollianco
every clear night in soveral nooo orl curcta obvarving Programs ad
woll as oxy repping peegraa at tho vericuo locations Listed tolew,
Althosg: tho ettmnticn of thos agtronemcrs 46 Largoly directed
towisd ddortiftcd ratht® than uaidestified obdects, 10 cans of ony
striting maideatificd objest ts-knowa to Dr o Page oc Dr. Wigmore SH oo
an object would most certainly ba reported sf fourd om patrol pistco.

A e529 waa elted wiero en-astronesce refused to fnteorups his
exposura in order to-photograya-ea alicged sighting ine different
pert of the ohys This led Dr. yaek to cay that, if-a program of - a
watching ‘could be an caganst of plarned eatronoaiced pregrenty” Mtths.— -—----
bone vents BS sivolves and thas tho _tosined astroreticel pereonnod _

michs pastearaps a sighting. ot ca mnidsntificd objets >

ouasles oP Bose of thaas progran? end thelr dizecters are --- ae

“|

mal

w=

pelieved £o_bat

a, Tarverd Univoretty, C:: sesiégo ad Hey Mico (acteor patrol) =

t. Yorkea Ovserratory, University of Chiesco and Fert Dovdo, Taras |

feoveral procranz)=Holnel (suo otac)y Futper: (asteroids) s——--—-—>
Mergia (wide engie camera).

c, Unixassisy of Alaska, faisranis- (ayrorad) ssi v0 oo

_ hg . eere .
+ Oncervatrry, OLbat (noteora)— iin

4. Denfaton
a. Feller Ghesrratevy, Calirornie (ster mrp). -Hinkouskt
S20 ‘ - Cats _, . nym
£, id os Soussvatery, Céliferaia (igre spe E2239
\
\ f
\

wee

eo aes!

ne Faint

ere

. tal
28 emigre a wrens Pen 5

+

Fh A ORO re re ry:

.

t vas agresd by tho Panel that no governmont-upontored progrea
Of enstical nitioneuide eky patvol fo vorthundls at the prosent time, -
aml that ths encouragcnsct of emstour extronomure to unsortake gutch
@ procrin cigat hive tho adverse offist of overecmphcoising "flying = |
peuces? stestcos in the reblic nind.  Rowsver, the tems of redar'scops
enzsran for recosding pomlier redar cshoc? would ocrv9 Goverol pure
porn, Iecinding tho bottor underetancing of radar intorferemo as. _.
woll ap identifiertion of U.r.0.°6.

RAMVIROW SLOT MITEL TTP REDE

4a charesteriotic problaa ef rader operation wherein the pulog

etary) (of appectirateiy tho came freptoncy) froa station A my ba. -

piske up oa the -ssregn of st.tion B ard choy ev e highsapocd trek

es sceivs of dot? iis Pocorited to have prembly-causcd-a nase of

U.F.O; reports. ‘hia problca ime undcvlixel by inferzation reelvcdi-- -— =

§roicating ADS conswa Su colving this problan ef sigtsl ide fection =~
bofcrs eatvice usa_of very bighespeca adrcsalt om govided niesiles ~~

(295822956), DF. Psvimar oolievca that or ansver to this predles
wap tho ucs of a Sesnpler flicr? in the reoaiving clrovit. Dr. Alvaro:
sugvectel that the prodlea right bo batter solved ty the use of a
Neoutrolicd jittcs” waerein the opacator receiving Mosry Laat tracks

few thy order cf 100Cr 10,000 mapvhe) would operetve e ehrait which
woud alter -aliensie his atatioals pulss Scquency mete, If tae olecal
rotoived en the coreca hed tern cau et by uur dncesferenes with

eveshe ctattor. tie track would now cues dtself as e Alfforent dietiary |


een HR NOUR cake tthe ge ica ge te ae

etn eee ates ames Hater Ae

We = ete on

menace dn

wits

.— . tye .
GPUS Sev are gh ey, vaptreme a PMc,

oa tage,

2 II RE, EEO TR worgeg we,

ss

Aue

er, Alvertz wat able quieviy to poin.d cut that the resordcd cata werd 1 8

“Noth view) gud coder resopnit

<REEOling

fra: tig eniits of tre ceveiny 10 1t ot4ll sppcarod ct ell, De. Aivevoz == — >

Laas gach eel rte) sslovdea wat oineler end canid eoct mish lees than

hee

4 *"Qosobse Pie

Meee wee ar)

oar
«emer ee o =

RETRY TDP COUR ORAS LEE CUDA

Bene ete cee ~

Sito puted coves vores osmntacds ef2 6% Polersr Mountain, Colifernta,

foe k

Ome 2 AG, thon Gombe rar ecraecsts woul “off coals ver a fo. occondat,
wpRveviiy vats o SY? of Pipire-onusers wag ooucmved wicowulys ard “wo, a

gucieu of cycarvevtleny by the °Lca Alans Bod Watehory Assestatien’® Seca

Sate nee

fugust 1359 to Janucry 1951, vata cemulc rey coireidircs countess bohoved ©

quecely. Civeutt diosnsarns end resexds vuoroe avadladic fev tho lnettao, and oo  -

weioubteduy dus to inttimmoental efforts that vould hive tosa estogesace.

a0 Buon bh, tse Gapethensed oecr vase.
The orwiuecton that radlescvive orfcets wero ooreulated with ©. : ee

Vridonlifdcd Line ob picets im thoae two cauco van, thirsYote, rescin. eT

mg esky

BUATIOUL YA

’
me ea te oe

The Pesw.ts contopt of a treed education provtan Intograting

a +

ovo ofall concerned cgencles uas that 10 chould have tuo major

t-

Tang Gio4ning ei wecldiresily ia prepsr sieogriticon of umuclly
phiacte rtd objeso> fe 20, tev +, adrara® volleatiens) na uoll cs

mare cencerecd. Thore vould bo ror;

ae Chew fe

ee
rp)

- aoe Ne


RAN OD eee ge

te mytee

seating a

1 apn ye

ae

~w

sate

She De
1 tegen ita

é

:

nee, ghee UM a eye,

é
a dad Se

»

me gee

levels in mich cducation fren enlisted porecanol to eccmind amd retestch

Porsomal, Reistive e:phasiv end desvoo of ealansiion of different

Progrens would corre3ye~ul to tho catesosics of duty (2, Cue THORP operators

Pilots; ceatrol teusr oncratera: Grow Coccever 6 Les pissentels end

effSeers eA oriistet van

Wee ao vt

TCOURt in a mastisd reduction 44 “pert s canted Uy rcantdfieatios

cx ret at*: suk, ee A, eee

the oSaniens? wa vewld woul fare

hy "fMiying couseta? whieh tedez

2 ay “ “st 4 “ Tate Sergi - Pe Fi sete tt wet on.
Mais cduration eowld bo aseceseiehsd by mus eedia evsa an % Te ITESOGR,

mee me Soares aw A vate 6S Ae Dine Tae pd reer. a
Tae 0203 or Tullo Se ElT2 POP me ce Metie- Slang G2 ftlu stu t4t10n Ve

b os
rotum@atsca if tuo Sscosou de tas. Sacha BEC EOD The ter

redves ha current ccatilisy | ayy Sts ; Wtydeabte thete _
mAeapia. LMS teal Lnstcd thes thas

;
i
ote map: a me Sea) cee eee a. oe | re. nn eS
Ah PG. CRC ba oot uk aA wees uit neous Saat cote: Tey WITS
tee FS es eC eee Seeces ©
bre ies tt ea DL. Ya ot J Cutie. teeth G .
ase * ae . rn . os es ° on are yous mF her eee © ant)
Fete | on ow Se wa Poe Tiss cr cree Ps . i ed .
. - a ._ - .- . = tes . ws
eros we ere sta wee BY ao ar or en SOINGI
ce -
. aa
wee
an : . - . - . wee {
' 4


ran

Bey ea eis

sen

4

Saad

A iene A A ah RN tl ve eR Ne MOE I OT

ae

= hee

sate

dN yewtageyig sr:

Stalch Lo in en Pte

yun

Mayr ee on ggene
whine pee

ry

,
a 26 Sven an

obese

een

Mors®. (u otudy in the poschology of panic, written nbsut the fcnous
Ovooa eliss redis teentees$ fa 19:£) awl his alste poofernad advanacd

Jabossicry chviles in tho flold cf porecptica, Tho nonea of Don Moraio

: of Miehteaa) end ico Restea veru mentiencd ea possibly

entries co.

and

; sontbart papeneleriowts ~ Also, cumers Pankldar with ae

5 4, -3 & Syne — “” Lf on ~~ ;
mats ear vieatien tcchniqusa,cpsmunpalon advertising apart, vovld ts :

ylsfal, Arcings Ccdfsoy ves noutlencd os posololy yo vedusole ehcanak”

> Pa - “ ~ ..- Pawan ee!
, of cartiin Tovola.s Dre Rotini.

2
ie
Q
%
ras
J
,*
fee
&

4
9S
B
fae)
ue
cs
on
ke
#
oO
“

Hf Cerawles!

mggastel the U.S. Mavy (CES) &.sotol Devices Gentes, Sania Polat, La Tos” -

&3 6 potrwifally voluablo cegaulewiee 42 a97iss dn cock en edvcstioz=l

Peom ns, BS . a
4gcatificsiaoa cvring tha post wis uaz elicd oo an omuplo 62 o ciaiigs io”

céveatior:) totic. eo, “nien cado Worla Mae lil tretaicg

Mins (notion wistura and-alics civips) wes alto: BULTIC A aguctles ==

*» AD, re

Walt Diracy, Ibs. roirsesd eartewn— Dy. Kensk cevgcntes thay seg 0 =

‘

ge itow cowrenecrs if the Us 8 mist boo potonttol somes of cathutie —
St45 telcad “vo cproad the gospaa?. Th 09,

clubs, high. “Se lewcrcala

pleased vo ecapcscvo in tho shoving oF Copmovtesy_irye posien pistes +

. - ~ f ~ oa . . Fan ~ . ee pte
42 prervercA dn ect anbeserting mount. Tha an0 OF Wy Catse engwing. —-——.. —

firs: tho “rpmtesrt ant tha tuy "expe ration’ vweuld bo for

i

ting PancL tattered uas momo i

To plan it iotists rechsouvereets
rein bunts Tas cerrest daveoticshery prous od ATIC vould, ef rasescity,

hevo tO by Glocals trtegsatad feo capraet with veapexe to nos oaly the


eh tee

oad
’
é

wytte re

coo)

Pee net eae

tenn ane
eee,

se wey
tye

fomrta
ae Crs er a)

rer ist ho!
fet

3

fe Art et,
om,

at
oo
’ .
.
. ~ -
* ave
wBateee e -
. . oe
teow
+e rd
N

a eee em tee

.

‘ wae ft
- cary ov ate
or eee Pre et eee
Pn Se cs eby ee Se -- >» wit
weet, tae wean’
. 8 ne vows
© oh has *
a wae el
ee eos + eee Ot - wat
feo ps ft. we ee eee tee
er es wees . a
. : : . 2 ata - o. .
“yae ct . woes eee wae . Loe 4sige
~ 2! - wee we ON * , id eee ae te
: re
a . O gt te 1 so.
sean ote ee ret won Ss y . Nee
ww TT he i vas a) todos ee eS
.
: . ’ eos .
. oe : a ae . . " wot ge tae Vboawle,
“ or a Tete “aoe weet lee ee a : »
es ves sot ee - tom ote e » tow :
rn . mar pay ee ee wot. ee y
4
- wo. * . ee Ne toe
: 2 stort. Tate Boe nn rns tien H
‘
i
z
- - . . ‘ -
. : Pee 4 ‘ : . ' - - .
we i
t
. ’ . :
: hee ws ope ny % . ro. ‘
2h. . a are omy ‘ a oe bee Hee i
i
. oa . . ' . ° - 3
oan ae . . rn tA : : " : os
seh os See CG wee : eo
’ \


cotati ene REINA I Mm =

eee yg here

se Maye od, Pree wi otto *t

ant gio:
I

a ore

seep:

ee!

Af

woud bs tha paebegrarhing of @ptilow tia

yndes sinthea> veasher condition at the site.

wpltero and a supcomtr ctcr

Sece (raining fLlne uowld ca nesesceyy ’y addicion, tne Faxed
ATIC*S EMforin, HenLsecy
most uSerul in ingbeni: ag om 2

mEeGIGONE

ad dence comageeancs weeps m2 te
2S eS a ey ee

eS ee
dee Same ree

ae a a ea ocsATD eS .
mon? . eee) A

™

Related files

Connected through the network